Drugstore eyeliners can truly deliver a smudge-proof, long-lasting look – but are they all created equal? When it comes to finding the best options, you’ll want to weigh factors like formula, pigment payoff, and wear time. Luckily, our top 5 picks offer a range of high-performance features to elevate your eye makeup game. From creamy, 16-hour pencils to precise liquid liners, there’s a drugstore eyeliner that’ll transform your look and have you feeling confident all day. Ready to discover your new holy grail?
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Never Fail Mechanical Pencil Eyeliner
If you’re searching for a reliable, long-lasting drugstore eyeliner that delivers on its promises, the L’Oreal Paris Infallible Never Fail Mechanical Pencil Eyeliner is worth considering.
With its creamy formula that glides on effortlessly and stays put for up to 16 hours, this mechanical pencil eyeliner is a great option for those seeking smudge-proof and waterproof eye makeup.
The built-in sharpener guarantees you can always achieve the perfect tip for precise application, while the soft pencil tip allows for easy blending.
Whether you’re going for a classic or bold eye look, this versatile eyeliner can help you achieve your desired result. And at a budget-friendly price, it’s a fantastic value compared to other high-end options on the market.
However, some users have reported the color pencil falling out or breaking, and achieving a fine line may take some practice.
Best For: Those seeking a long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof drugstore eyeliner that delivers on its promises.
Pros:
Creamy formula that glides on effortlessly
Stays put for up to 16 hours without fading
Versatile for creating classic to bold eye designs
Cons:
Some users experienced the color pencil falling out and breaking
Difficulty in achieving a fine line with the pencil tip
Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil, Cosmic Black 10
For those seeking a nourishing and long-lasting eyeliner that’s gentle on sensitive eyes, the Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil, Cosmic Black 10 is an excellent choice.
Formulated with olive oil and rainforest shea butter, this pencil glides on smoothly and lasts all day without fading or smudging.
The subtle light diffusers within the pencil make the whites of your eyes appear whiter, while the built-in sharpener allows for precise application and definition.
The contoured smudger enables you to create a soft, blended, smoky-eye look.
Dermatologist- and ophthalmologist-tested, this eyeliner is gentle and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
Compared to similar products, it offers better staying power and a more affordable price point, making it a top pick for drugstore eyeliners.
Best For: The Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil, Cosmic Black 10 is best for those with sensitive eyes who want a long-lasting, smudge-proof eyeliner that nourishes with olive oil and shea butter.
Pros:
Glides on smoothly and lasts all day without fading or smudging
Hypoallergenic and gentle on sensitive eyes
Contoured smudger allows for a soft, blended, smoky-eye look
Cons:
Some users found it too expensive
One user did not like the product and felt it did not live up to expectations
Some users experienced issues with shipping and customs fees
Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner, Onyx, 1 Count
The Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner is an excellent choice for those seeking a long-lasting, smudge-resistant eyeliner that glides on smoothly and delivers rich pigment.
With its self-sharpening tip, you’ll enjoy a precise application that’s easy to use.
While some users found it difficult to apply, especially on darker skin tones, others praised its performance, noting it stayed on well even in hot weather.
However, a few users reported issues with smudging and the eyeliner not staying on as long as they’d hoped.
Overall, it’s a solid drugstore option that provides good value for the price and is recommended for makeup classes due to its long-lasting wear.
Best For: Those seeking a long-lasting, smudge-resistant eyeliner with a self-sharpening tip for precise application.
Pros:
Long-lasting and easy to use
Glides on smoothly with rich pigment
Stays on well, even in hot weather
Cons:
Difficult to apply, especially on darker skin tones
Revlon’s Skinny Liquid Eyeliner is a go-to choice for those seeking a long-lasting, precise eye look with its 10-hour wear and ultra-fine 0.1 millimeter brush tip.
The highly pigmented formula delivers bold, even color in a single stroke, while the longwear technology prevents smudging, fading, or transfer.
Users praise the eyeliner’s ease of use, with the fine tip allowing for seamless cat eyes, subtle definition, and feline flicks.
Though not waterproof, the eyeliner still performs well in rainy conditions. Some users report occasional smudging after several hours, but the majority rave about its long-lasting wear.
For a bolder eye look, pair it with Revlon’s So Fierce Mascara.
Ophthalmologist-tested and suitable for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes, this affordable drugstore find is a reliable option for all-day, smudge-proof definition.
Best For: Revlon Skinny Liquid Eyeliner is best for those seeking a long-lasting, precise eye look with its ultra-fine 0.1 millimeter brush tip.
Pros:
Highly pigmented, bold, even, streak-free color in a single stroke
10-hour wear with no smudging, fading, or transfer
Easy to use with the fine tip for creating seamless cat eyes, subtle definition, and feline flicks
Cons:
Not waterproof, though still performs well in rainy conditions
Some users report occasional smudging after several hours of wear
Applicator may not be suitable for those who prefer a thicker, more solid-tipped eyeliner
COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil, 110 Black Brown (2 Count)
COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil, 110 Black Brown (2 Count) is an ideal choice for those seeking a budget-friendly, easy-to-apply eyeliner that delivers a natural, flattering look.
The smooth glide of this eyeliner allows you to draw precise lines or softly smudge for a sultry, smoky eye.
Though it’s not waterproof, the creamy formula is long-wearing and won’t run or fade throughout the day.
While some customers found the Black Brown shade a bit too dark, most praise its versatility, allowing you to create both subtle and bold eye looks.
At an affordable price point, this COVERGIRL eyeliner is a great option for anyone looking to elevate their makeup routine without breaking the bank.
Best For: COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil, 110 Black Brown (2 Count) is best for those seeking an affordable, easy-to-apply eyeliner that provides a natural, flattering look.
Pros:
Smooth glide for precise application and blending
Creamy formula that is long-wearing and won’t run or fade
Versatile for creating both subtle and bold eye looks
Cons:
Not waterproof, may run if you get your face wet
Requires sharpening
Some customers found the Black Brown shade too dark
Factors to Consider When Choosing Drugstore Eyeliners
When looking for the best drugstore eyeliner, consider how creamy and gliding the application is.
Pay attention to the pigment intensity and richness, as well as the eyeliner’s longevity and smudge-resistance.
Additionally, think about the precision of application and whether the eyeliner feels comfortable and gentle on your eyes.
Creamy Application and Glide
A creamy, glide-on formula is a key factor to ponder when choosing a drugstore eyeliner, as it can provide a smooth, even application that’s gentle on the delicate eye area.
The right formula blends rich, creamy pigments with a soft, smooth pencil tip, allowing you to achieve that coveted creamy eyeliner look and feel.
This can be especially beneficial for mature eyelids, as a creamy formula is less likely to tug or pull on the skin.
Moreover, a creamy eyeliner that glides on seamlessly can help you create a more precise and defined eye look, whether you’re going for a subtle cat-eye or a bold, feline flick.
The blendable tip also gives you the flexibility to achieve a smoky-eye effect, while a more precise tip allows you to make a statement with a dramatic line.
Ultimately, a creamy, glide-on eyeliner from the drugstore can be your secret to long-lasting, smudge-proof color that stays put for up to 16 hours.
Pigment Intensity and Richness
In addition to a creamy, glide-on formula, the intensity and richness of a drugstore eyeliner’s pigment are essential factors to ponder when making your selection.
You’ll want a formula that delivers bold, saturated color that doesn’t require tedious layering or struggle to achieve your desired look. The right pigment intensity can make all the difference, whether you prefer a subtle, understated line or a bold, dramatic eye.
Look for eyeliners that boast highly-pigmented formulas that pack a punch. Avoid formulas that appear sheer or chalky, as they’ll likely require multiple swipes to build up color.
Opt for eyeliners that glide on smoothly and evenly, depositing rich, impactful color in a single stroke. The richer the pigment, the more defined and vibrant your eye look will appear.
Pay attention to the undertones as well, as cooler-toned pigments can create a sleek, sophisticated look, while warmer tones add depth and dimension. With the right pigment intensity, you’ll achieve effortlessly chic, long-lasting eye definition.
Longevity and Smudge-Resistance
Longevity and smudge-resistance are essential factors to ponder when selecting drugstore eyeliners, as you’ll want a formula that won’t budge or fade throughout the day.
Many long-lasting eyeliner pencils can stay put for up to 16 hours without smudging or fading, making them perfect for your daily wear.
Smudge-proof eyeliner formulas are also a fantastic option, as they can resist smudging and fading, even in hot or humid conditions, ensuring a flawless eye look all day long.
Additionally, waterproof eyeliner pencils are a godsend for active individuals or those with oily skin, as they can withstand tears, sweat, and humidity.
However, keep in mind that some eyeliner pencils may require a primer to extend their wear and prevent smudging, especially on oily eyelids.
Ultimately, the longevity and smudge-resistance of your drugstore eyeliner will depend on your individual skin type, eyelid texture, and environmental factors, so be sure to read reviews and test products before making a purchase.
Precision of Application
Achieving a precise eyeliner application is often a top priority when selecting a drugstore option, as a fine-tipped and easy-to-control formula can make all the difference in creating your desired eye look.
When it comes to precision, look for eyeliners that offer an ultra-fine 0.1mm tip, allowing you to draw the sharpest, most defined lines. A self-sharpening tip is also a handy feature, keeping the point consistent for each application.
To achieve a softer, blended effect, seek out an eyeliner with a contoured smudger tip – this can help diffuse the line for a smoother, more seamless finish.
The formula itself also plays a role in precision; generally, gel and liquid eyeliners provide a more precise application than pencils. Of course, your own skill level is a factor too – with practice, you’ll become a pro at applying eyeliner with a steady hand and an expert eye.
No matter your expertise, the right precision-focused eyeliner can elevate your makeup routine.
Comfort and Gentleness
When selecting a drugstore eyeliner, prioritizing comfort and gentleness can guarantee a smooth and irritation-free application.
Opting for formulas that are ophthalmologist-tested and hypoallergenic helps minimize the risk of eye discomfort or sensitivity. Additionally, eyeliners infused with nourishing ingredients like olive oil and shea butter can soothe and hydrate the delicate eye area, providing a more comfortable wear throughout the day.
Look for eyeliners that glide on effortlessly without tugging or pulling on the delicate eyelid skin. Smooth, gliding application is a good indicator of a gentle formula.
Some drugstore eyeliners are specifically designed for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, making them an ideal choice for those who require extra gentleness around the eyes.
To confirm the eyeliner suits your individual needs, be sure to read reviews and check the ingredient list before making a purchase.
Versatile Looks and Finishes
In addition to comfort and gentleness, the versatility of a drugstore eyeliner’s looks and finishes is a crucial element to ponder when selecting the right product for your needs.
Look for eyeliners that can create a range of finishes, from matte to shimmery, to suit your personal style preferences.
Whether you’re aiming for a subtle, natural look or a bold, dramatic statement, the right eyeliner should be able to deliver.
Consider options with built-in smudgers or soft pencil tips that allow you to achieve a blended, smoky eye effect, adding depth and dimension to your peepers.
Versatility is key, so an eyeliner that can be used to draw thin, precise lines or thick, cat-eye flicks is an ideal choice.
The ability to use the eyeliner on both the upper lash line and waterline further enhances its value in your makeup routine, ensuring you can create a variety of alluring looks with ease.
Brand Reputation and Value
Reputable brands like L’Oreal and Maybelline often deliver high-quality drugstore eyeliners that outperform their price tags.
You can trust that these well-known names invest in rigorous research and development to create innovative formulas that last all day without smudging or fading.
But brand reputation isn’t everything – the true value of an eyeliner lies in its long-term performance and cost-effectiveness.
Some lesser-known drugstore brands may offer comparable quality at a lower price point, so it’s worth exploring options from brands like Neutrogena that prioritize customer satisfaction.
Look for features like easy returns and exchanges, which demonstrate a brand’s commitment to stand behind its products.
And don’t forget to weigh the range of shades and finishes available – a brand that caters to diverse preferences is more likely to have an eyeliner that perfectly suits your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Do I Apply Eyeliner for a Flawless Cat-Eye Look?
To achieve a flawless cat-eye look, start by holding your eyelid taut. Apply the liner in short, feathery strokes, following the natural shape of your eye. Finish by extending the line slightly past the outer corner for a dramatic effect.
What Are the Best Techniques for Tightlining the Eyes?
Ye olde tightlining technique requires a steady hand and precision. Gently pull your lid taut and apply liner to the upper waterline, working from the inner to outer corner. Blink slowly to guarantee an even, long-lasting application.
Are Drugstore Eyeliners Suitable for Sensitive Skin Types?
Many drugstore eyeliners are made with sensitive skin in mind. Look for formulas labeled ‘hypoallergenic’ or ‘ophthalmologist-tested’ to certify they won’t irritate your delicate eyes. Just do a patch test first to be safe.
How Do I Remove Waterproof Eyeliner Without Irritation?
I know waterproof eyeliner can be a pain to remove, but don’t worry – you can do it gently. Use a oil-based makeup remover and cotton pads, then follow up with a mild cleanser. This’ll remove it without irritating your skin.
Can I Use Drugstore Eyeliners for Both Everyday and Bold Looks?
Drugstore eyeliners can work for both everyday and bold looks. They’re versatile and budget-friendly. Just select a formula that suits your desired effect – liquid for sharp lines, pencil for a smudgier look. Have fun experimenting!
Conclusion
You’ll get a long-lasting, smudge-proof look with these top drugstore eyeliners.
While they deliver on performance, it’s worth investigating the truth behind the theory that drugstore cosmetics are inferior to high-end brands.
Rigorous testing may reveal these affordable options perform just as well, if not better, than their pricier counterparts.
